Leeds Music Scene

Gig review of The Tennessee Traincrash + The Barbs + No Problem Disko

YouTube Google RSS Feed

Posted by .

Reviewed on 1st January 2004.

 
 

The Tennessee Traincrash

Live at The Vine on Thursday, 23rd October 2003

It's been a weird day. October has gone from cold to colder to coldest. Today, the corn exchange and I witnessed Rik Mayall buying a shit t-shirt (emblazoned with "No-one knows I'm a lesbian" or a slogan of the same ilk) from my mate's shop. It rained, off and on (and off). The unpleasant day seems to be grinding to an equally cold and unpleasant end. Still, the opportunity to go see some bands in town is a much appreciated intermission from the local brat kids chucking fireworks at my house and our dog. Bring on the Vine.

Opening act No Problem Disko are simply a bunch of schoolgirls in a band. They occasionally sound reminiscent of the mighty Sonic Youth, which is good, even if this is a diapered and cuddled baby incarnation. However, these guys have no songs and not much musicality, which is bad. The timid and frankly woeful singer fails to convey any message, melody or character. Maybe she'll grow into it in time. I don't know. I get the feeling these girls aren't ready to be a band yet.

The next band is the reason I'm here. They're from London and they started touring the whole of the UK yesterday, in Glasgow. They have a single out called "Massive Crush", on Mother Tongue records. I heard it on the radio a few weeks ago and became ensnared. They're heading off to Amsterdam to play with The Darkness before long. They are The Barbs, and in my humble opinion, their front-man Tim looks quite a bit like a young Bob Geldof.

The Barbs are armed to the teeth with wit and riffs, every pounding song like a series of mini explosions. They shake and kick their way through a lightning set, throwing out hook after brilliant hook. The two singers, Tim and Amy, holler obscure narratives at each other, puerile but somehow embodying the flipside of juvenile. The chorus' are monstrous - catchy as fuck. The Barbs latch onto some primal love of basic driving grooves and bark it back out in the shape of 3 minute aggro-pop pelvic thrusts. Un-thwartable rocking; playful, abrasive and supreme. The night is theirs, and I think they stole my heart. or my hearing at least.

I gave The Barbs some obligatory congratulations after their incredible set. Amy said "thanks" and told me to email her. Maybe it's a bit sexist and gross, but I find girls in bands so inexplicably cool. I can offer no justification. Anyway, she touched my leg - I'm not sure whether she meant to, but she definitely touched it. I think she fell in love with me. but I'm not sure. Talk about mixed signals. Women. Hmph.

The Tennessee Traincrash are a cake I don't really want to bake - my mind is split as to whether I should voice my true feelings about them. Personally, I appreciate them about as much as having uninvited willies thrust in my ears; ghastly. One of many disasters that sat cackling in the wings as it became socially acceptable to have never picked up an instrument before getting signed and famous.

Ok, there is a chance that I just don't "get it". Let's dwell on this; I must reluctantly admit that the days when irony was for the elite or intelligible are gone and dead. A Pandora's Box of fashion re-releases, novelty film re-makes and musical re-hashes has been prized open. Irony is mainstream, and accessible to every trendy high street spaz, regardless of intellect. As a result, musically inept dirge-merchants like the Tennessee Traincrash can bypass any quality nets/crap filters/whatever to be hailed as the zeitgeist - or worse, musically valuable. I don't buy it. Is irritating feedback and poorly executed non-music IN? I feel a bit alien. My brain begins to corrupt and ache. I feel unqualified to stay to the end. I have to leave (proudly displaying my The Barbs badge).

 

Comments

All replies to this article. Log in to post a reply.

On 25th October 2003 at 13:24 Anonymous 629 wrote...

What a good review!!
I enjoyed reading this loads, I think because of it's honesty.
I'm absolutely sick of people jumping on band wagons and neglecting to acknowledge how they really feel. It's so easy to say- wow, you guys are really cool, when you actually spent their whole set looking around you and wondering when it will end so you can sit down and start having a conversation again instead of standing up and feeling bored and uncomfortable.
Good for you for having the guts to say how you really feel- and for thinking about it and explaining why.

It's so easy to dismiss a band straight off, just as easy as jumping up their ass- but thinking about your reasponse and why they made you feel that way is something to be admired.

Good work you. Good luck with Miss Barbs- seduce her via email- she will be yours, oh yes, she will be yours! (maybe)

 

On 25th October 2003 at 21:38 Anonymous 13 wrote...

Cathy ... sorry, but I feel got at here. Let me explain. I wrote very enthusiastic reviews of the Tennessee Train Crash a little while ago. Because I enjoyed their CD and their show a lot. I know I'm mad, and people do get at me from time to time for writing no more and no less than I think. Airbourne (misspelled youth from Liverpool) was a recent example. So when you claim that "I'm absolutely sick of people jumping on band wagons and neglecting to acknowledge how they really feel." I would have felt a whole lot better if you'd made it clear that you weren't suggesting that Dan's lively and entertaining piece was unique on LMS. I assume (in the absence of any evidence to the contrary) that he was as honest as we all try to be when we write our stuff. Maybe you were thinking about the NME? This message was last edited on 25/10/03 21.39:08

 

On 26th October 2003 at 02:19 Anonymous 291 wrote...

Gotta say, i was at that gig, (in some capacity or other, ok,only the barman) and i really enjoyed it. BUT, the reviewers opinion is his own, and thats fair enough, one persons opinion is exactly that. Don't bother slagging off reviewers, they serve a very important purpose. I personally don't agree with the man, but thats not a problem. His review - his opinion. Simple as that.

 

On 26th October 2003 at 11:10 Dave LMS wrote...

Sam, I don't think Cathy was having a go at you, or LMS. The point is that this review had honesty written all over it, and that Dan explained his feelings and opinions well. For this I think Cathy was impressed enough to highlight Dan's review as having had a positive impact on her. I don't think she was trying to diss anyone, individually or collectively - though the NME can get a kicking if we want Neil - you're a barman (again) ?This message was last edited on 26/10/03 11.15:39

 

On 26th October 2003 at 11:29 Anonymous 291 wrote...

Aye, you'd know that if you ever went to any gigs Dave!

 

On 26th October 2003 at 11:36 Dave LMS wrote...

Yeah, I know. Slacker. I intend to be out again soon...

 

On 27th October 2003 at 14:38 Anonymous 629 wrote...

I'm very sorry Sam I haven't even read your review so I wasn't getting at you.
I was only giving praise where I feel it's due.
I have enormous respect for honesty shown in any capacity, reviewing or otherwise- it can both cause and solve problems- but I believe it really is the best policy.

As far as band wagons are concerned I'm as guilty as anyone for jumping on them, but sometimes you need to step off them and admit you're wrong (case in point my eager rushing to the cockpit last year to see the thrills after reading a gushing review in the nme- I had to diss my friends birthday and everything- I soon saw I was wrong and had to eat humble pie big time) that said, I'm not saying the traincrash are rubbish -I HAVEN'T SEEN THEM.
My comments were about reviewing as an abstract not any specific review.

Anyway, what I was really getting at was the thought that had gone into the article- rather than just saying what he thought he should say the reviewer produced his own opinion and explained why he felt that way. I liked that.

Hope that's cleared things up a bit.

 

On 27th October 2003 at 14:55 Anonymous 13 wrote...

cleared very nicely - thanks. But have you also noticed how often we see the expression of negative emotions as somehow more honest than attempts to describe the positive ones? And sometimes it isn't fair to stick those emotions (positive or negative) onto the artist ... It's an honest story, but should it honestly be aimed at the band you are reviewing? Difficult stuff. I think Dan was clear enough - certainly clear enough for me to understand what his gripe was and for me to feel comfortable about disagreeing with him.

PS I read all your stuff Cathy - and I think it's very good indeed. It's really encouraging to have you and now several others joining in - the quality goes up and the number of artists who get some attention goes up. This message was last edited on 27/10/03 14.56:09

 

On 29th October 2003 at 16:29 Anonymous 1102 wrote...

i was not at this gig but have seen the traincrash before and i think that people should be respectful to the reviews of dan, if you see some of the petty reviews of any band the traincrash drummer writes in his fanzine you would see this, still he is entitled to his opinion as is anyone else, i personally think theres more to music than haircuts, trends and fads, at the end of the day its talent that counts, nothing else!

 

On 30th October 2003 at 11:36 Anonymous 1135 wrote...

I wasn't at the gig either but in the past I've liked Tennessee Traincrash, the vocals reminded me a little of The Rogers Sisters. PS in light of the above discussion I plan to set up a sister site called 'Leeds Reviewer Scene', a good idea, no?This message was last edited on 30/10/03 11.38:15

 

On 30th October 2003 at 12:37 Anonymous 963 wrote...

ok - i was gonna stay out of this 'cos as you've all so politely pointed out, you are all entitled to your opinions BUT....PLEASE get your facts straight before you go making a fool of yourself, I'm saying this for the sake of your own dignity.

Our drummer DOES NOT write a fanzine. Nor has he ever, as far as I'm aware.

Oh, and for the record...I haven't had a hair cut since Easter. Sorry.

 

On 31st October 2003 at 12:32 Dave LMS wrote...

Get a haircut. Hmmph, students...

 

On 31st October 2003 at 17:41 Anonymous 1055 wrote...

Here's my two penneth. Met Hayley and Alex at our Vine gig last night. They are very pleasant folks. They gave me a copy of their demo and it RULES! It RULES, do you hear me??!! Excellent. Ain't seen 'em live yet but hope to rectify this Saturday, poverty permitting. That is all.

 

On 1st November 2003 at 10:18 Anonymous 251 wrote...

Hello Mr Noah you crazy mofo!

Terence, someone did set up a Leeds reviewers website before. I think it died.

 
 
 

Photos

1 photos • Upload a photo

 
 

Bands

3 bands associated with this article.

The Tennessee Traincrash

Who Went

0 attendees

I Went