Leeds Music Scene

Gig review of White Rose Movement + Protocol + Dead Disco

YouTube Google RSS Feed

Posted by .

Reviewed on 27th September 2005.

 
 

White Rose Movement

Live at Cockpit on Monday, 26th September 2005

Well the night had a nice little twist right at the beginning on this occasion. I arrive at the venue all geared up to go on the hunt for the tour manager again (about 7.10pm) and get turned away. WHY you ask (even if you don't I'm going to tell you). Because they have decided they will not let anyone in till 8 (even though it says doors 7pm) so now I have an hour to kill. After having a nice 30 minute conversation with a homeless person about the economy I decide to head back.

LUCK STRIKES.

Outside was the tour manager, THANK GOD. After achieving to arrange an interview with White Rose Movement I head inside to check out Dead Disco.

First thing that strikes me is... it's a girl band. The ultimate hell when it comes to support bands. Now usually I would leave the room straight away after having a dry throated female roaring through the PA system, but to my relief (and I'm sure the relief of others) no screaming (insert happiness here). Dead Disco were a punky quartet that played what is to be perceived as the average support band's music. Nothing that you could honestly say was impressive, and you could tell this by how the crowd stayed well back from the speakers.

The lead singer tried to hit the high notes on several of her songs, but to be honest we all know that the majority of girls can do that and it all sounds the same, it's only impressive if you're a guy as it's quite rare that they can actually hit those kind of notes. All in all Dead Disco were nothing that special but not that bad either.

Now next up are a band called Protocol, who I am going to admit I have never heard of before, but am likely to hear more of in the future. Protocol are a highly original band with a very definitive sound. Polydor Records signed the band some years back and since then the band have been creating their perfect sounding album, whilst also writing songs for a well known artist that I am unable to divulge for legal reasons. They recently played to 2000 people at London's KOKO club.

I don't expect much out of support bands but for Protocol I really should have done. John Pritchard put so much energy into his performance, pouring his heart out for the crowd, who lapped up every bit of every note of every song. The turnout was actually bigger for Protocol by a fair amount than it was for White Rose Movement, not only that but Protocol got a much better reaction out of the crowd too. Come to think of it they might as well have headlined.

Their songs were remarkably upbeat and blended together unbelievably well, in particular their new single "She Waits For Me" where the song flowed perfectly and had the most addictive chorus. You could actually feel the energy from the band, and I can see their bigger gigs being vibrant with emotion and energy. As for arena shows, I would think we will be seeing them sooner than you think.

Now on to the band of the night White Rose Movement, or not as it would seem due to half of the congregation of fans leaving, rendering the room half empty. This was such a shame for the 80s influenced group simply because they played so well. Songs such as "Love is a number", "Girls in the back" and "Cruella" all have the unquestionable influence of bands such as New Order and the Cure. White Rose Movement gave it their all, and yet still no reciprocation from the crowd. Singer Finn Vine even declared that we were "awfully stagnant" which to be honest he was right about. I don't believe that keyboardist Taxxi or Finn actually helped the situation by performing in their extremely clichéd manner, showing little to no expression whatsoever.

Besides the lack of interaction on both ends (except the guitarists who weren't deterred by anything at all) White Rose Movement did play spectacularly well. Apart from a minor drum problem their actual musical performance was flawless. With their synthesiser-driven melodies and unmistakably harmonic vocals White Rose Movement could bring the 80s back. Perhaps when they get a little more well know and the album is released will we really start to see their live acts flourish.

 

Comments

All replies to this article. Log in to post a reply.

On 27th September 2005 at 21:50 Anonymous 1928 wrote...

It's rare these days that I'm incited to fly into a feminist rant, but I just couldn't let this one lie. All I've heard of Dead Disco are the tunes on their web site (which I thought were pretty good) so I can't comment on their live performance, but that's not really relevant here as it's the reviewer's blatant preconceptions and closed mindedness regarding girl bands that really PISSED ME OFF. AND I've just come back from yoga class so it was going to take something serious! Quote: "...it's a girl band. The ultimate hell when it comes to a support bands." - ignoring the typo, what the fuck??!! I doubt the quality of the band would have made much difference if that's the kind of attitude you go in to watching them with. And later: "The lead singer tried to hit the high notes on several of her songs, but to be honest we all know that the majority of girls can do that and it all sounds the same, it's only impressive if you're a guy as it's quite rare that they can actually hit those kind of notes" - jesus mate, stop with the generalising PLEASE! You really need to get out more and widen your knowledge and experience of females in bands. But perhaps avoid actually having a conversation with any of them cause you sound like someone who could easily put foot in mouth and receive swift kick to bollocks! If you want to widen your blatantly very narrow idea of girl bands, we dare you to come and see Bonsai Kittens' next gig (Tues 11 Oct @ Packhorse), but please try and leave your preconceptions at the door this time....

 

On 27th September 2005 at 22:06 Anonymous 4717 wrote...

i didnt mean so sound that bad, its just how its come out. im not going to argue because your right i do have a very narrow minded premeditated view of girl bands sorry if it annoys you. the fact is we all generalise sometimes its just the one time i have done it, it seems to of struck a nerve sorry.

 

On 28th September 2005 at 11:30 Anonymous 30 wrote...

"the fact is we all generalise sometimes" is another generalisation isn't it?

 

On 28th September 2005 at 12:37 Anonymous 4206 wrote...

Now I'm not the biggest fan of Dead Disco, but that review was awful mate. A Bonsai Kitten has covered all the main points, but can I just add that no one cares that you had an hour to kill or that you needed to meet the tour manager or whatever. Also, your writing style is about as incisive as a paper spoon, it almost makes me want to stop listening to music. You obviously don't like music very much if you "have a very narrow minded premeditated view of girl bands" - and why do you bother reviewing for LMS if you 'don't expect much out of support bands'. The mind boggles. Oh, and don't go thinking that your review 'touched a nerve' because it was genuinly controversial, it touched a nerve because it was SEXIST.

 

On 28th September 2005 at 13:35 Anonymous 4717 wrote...

Great

 

On 28th September 2005 at 13:52 Anonymous 4717 wrote...

i want to point out that none of you are perfect. now im not saying you think you are but its coming across like that so just back off. ok i get that the dead disco review was sexist. i get that it was controversial. leave it the fuck alone would you. and if you cant you need to seriously take at look at yourself before criticising me. leave the dead disco bit now ok. the only way to win an argument is to convince the other person your right otherwise there are no winners. so just let it be. NOW apart forom that what did anyone think of the protocol and WRM part. sarcasm and attempts of smart witty comments will just be ignored. "your writing style is about as incisive as a paper spoon" . - even though its negative at least my writing has been taken into account

 

On 28th September 2005 at 17:12 Anonymous 2871 wrote...

So is it ok for you to have a go at a band, but not ok for people to have a go at your reviews?

Come on, you need to be able to defend your own writing and opinions better than by saying 'fuck off, no-one's perfect'. I thing what you said was ignorant and pointless. As do the other people on here. Now tell us why it isn't...

 

On 28th September 2005 at 17:51 Michael Q wrote...

It's not just offensive, it's poorly written and hasn't been thought out at all.

 

On 28th September 2005 at 18:17 Anonymous 1227 wrote...

My advice for what it's worth, just read and re-read through work before it's submitted - think how it will sound to other people and whether they will like it or not (positive or negative review). Don't just write what comes into your head and be a little more succint. You won't go far wrong then.


You've made a terrible error - learn from it, draw a line and strive to improve your next review

 

On 28th September 2005 at 18:20 Anonymous 1227 wrote...

oh and flitting between past and present tenses is a no-no in my humble opinion.

 

On 28th September 2005 at 19:38 Anonymous 1928 wrote...

Have to agree with Tomas - just as any band performing in public must be ready to accept criticism as well as praise, so should any reviewer who puts his/her work in the public domain. Perhaps even more so, as reviewers have the potential to influence other people's attitudes and ideas so they should be accountable for their comments.

 

On 28th September 2005 at 23:17 Anonymous 4514 wrote...

Dear Ben Daure
Perhaps you should take a course in English Grammar before you write anymore reviews. Give up your day job!

 

On 28th September 2005 at 23:26 Dave LMS wrote...

With all due respect to anyone else thinking of posting here, I think (however valid they seem/are) that instead of going over the same points - once first raised that is - with everyone getting a 'dig in' people should look at how LaxtonsSuperb approached his feedback, and look at providing something worthwhile, constructive and useful so that Ben can read and move on, and you (the readers) will know you've made a difference if you see the improvements you suggest in later articles and reviews.

 

On 29th September 2005 at 12:51 Anonymous 4126 wrote...

I'm an American

 
 
 

Photos

1 photos • Upload a photo

 
 

Bands

3 bands associated with this article.

White Rose Movement

Dead Disco

"All the best female-fronted pop songs ever ('Atomic', 'Kids In America', anything involving Gwen Stefani), mashed up and sung out by an indie Alison Goldfrapp in a stripy prom dress. Better believe it, buddy" NME

Who Went

0 attendees

I Went